Your ankle works better, but the pain is still there. We explain a study co-authored by our clinic director.
Source of bibliographic details: PubMed (US National Library of Medicine), PMID: 37086907. This study was conducted at other medical institutions and does not report treatment outcomes from Ginza YR Clinic.
After total ankle replacement, both groups of patients improved in ankle function and walking ability, regardless of their depression scores before surgery.
Those with lower preoperative depression scores, however, reported less pain at six months and one year.
* This was a retrospective observational study of 20 patients. It shows an association, not cause and effect.
Ankle function has improved after surgery, yet the patient still feels pain. Why does this happen?
A study published in The Journal of Foot & Ankle Surgery explored this question by examining the relationship between mood before surgery and pain afterwards.
The researchers divided 20 patients who underwent total ankle replacement into two groups based on the median preoperative depression score. Both groups improved in ankle function and walking ability. At six months and one year, however, patients in the lower depression score group had better pain-related scores, indicating less pain and less interference with daily life.
Dr Junya Higuchi, director of Ginza YR Clinic, contributed to this research while working in the Department of Orthopaedic Surgery at Teikyo University Mizonokuchi Hospital. He is the paper’s second author.
What Did the Study Find?
Both groups improved in ankle function and walking ability
Patients improved after surgery regardless of whether their preoperative depression scores were higher or lower. No statistically significant differences between the groups were found in the functional assessments.
Patients with lower depression scores before surgery reported less pain afterwards
At six months and one year, the lower depression score group had significantly higher SAFE-Q pain-related scores. Higher scores indicate a better condition, meaning that patients in this group reported less pain and less impact on daily life.
Mood scores also improved in one group
In the lower preoperative depression score group, both depression and anxiety scores decreased significantly at one year. No statistically significant changes were observed in the higher score group.
How Was the Study Conducted?
The researchers reviewed clinical records and follow-up data from 20 patients who underwent total ankle replacement.
| Title | Association of Preoperative Depression Score With Outcomes of Transfibular Total Ankle Arthroplasty |
|---|---|
| Journal | The Journal of Foot & Ankle Surgery (2023; 62(5): 807–811) |
| Study design | Retrospective observational study |
| Institutions | Teikyo University Mizonokuchi Hospital and others (not Ginza YR Clinic) |
| Participants | 20 patients, with 10 in each group |
| Mean age | 75 years |
| Sex | 19 women and 1 man |
| Diagnoses | Osteoarthritis in 18 patients; rheumatoid arthritis in 2 |
| Surgical approach | Transfibular total ankle arthroplasty |
| Implant system | Trabecular Metal Total Ankle (TM Ankle) |
| Basis for grouping | Median preoperative HADS depression score (5.5) |
| DOI | 10.1053/j.jfas.2023.04.004 |
* Total ankle replacement involves replacing a severely damaged ankle joint with an artificial joint to relieve pain and improve function. In this study, surgeons accessed the joint from the outer side of the ankle through the fibula.
* A retrospective observational study looks back at the records of patients who have already been treated. It can show associations between factors and outcomes, but it cannot prove cause and effect.
Patients were grouped by their depression scores, rather than by whether they had a clinical diagnosis of depression.
How Was Recovery Assessed?
The study used four assessment tools to measure joint function, mobility, patients’ own experiences and mood.
| Assessment | What it measures |
|---|---|
| JSSF Ankle/Hindfoot Scale | Pain, joint function and alignment |
| Timed Up & Go test (TUG) | Time taken to stand up from a chair, walk three metres, turn, return and sit down |
| Self-Administered Foot Evaluation Questionnaire (SAFE-Q) | Patient-reported pain, physical function, daily activities and social participation, among other aspects of life |
| Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) | Anxiety and depressive symptoms |
JSSF, SAFE-Q and HADS assessments were completed before surgery, at six months and at one year. TUG was measured before surgery and at one year.
* Higher SAFE-Q scores indicate better outcomes in the area being assessed.
* Higher HADS scores indicate more pronounced anxiety or depressive symptoms.
Clinical assessments and patient questionnaires provide complementary information: how well someone can walk, how much pain they feel, and how their symptoms affect everyday life.
Functional Recovery: Both Groups Improved
Both groups showed improvements in joint function scores and walking test results compared with their preoperative assessments. No statistically significant differences were found between the groups.
These findings suggest that patients with higher depression scores before surgery can still achieve improvements in ankle function and walking ability.
A higher depression score alone is not enough to conclude that functional recovery will be poorer. Decisions about surgery should take into account the extent of joint damage, symptoms, overall health and the patient’s treatment goals.
Pain: Better Outcomes in the Lower Depression Score Group
The patient-completed SAFE-Q questionnaire revealed significant differences between the groups in pain-related scores.
| Pain-related score (median) | Lower depression score group | Higher depression score group |
|---|---|---|
| Six months after surgery | 78 | 44 |
| One year after surgery | 90 | 59 |
The differences were statistically significant at both time points.
Because higher SAFE-Q scores indicate better pain-related outcomes, patients in the lower depression score group reported less pain and less interference with daily life at both six months and one year.
The other four SAFE-Q domains (physical functioning and daily living, social functioning, general health and well-being, and shoe-related issues) showed no statistically significant differences between the groups after surgery.
These findings highlight why joint movement and walking tests alone cannot capture the full picture of recovery. Both groups improved in clinical measures of function, but their reported pain differed. Assessing recovery therefore requires both functional tests and patients’ own accounts of pain.
Does This Mean the Pain Has a Psychological Cause?
The study did not establish that.
It found an association between depression scores before surgery and pain afterwards. It did not prove that one caused the other, or identify the reason for persistent pain in each patient.
Ongoing pain after surgery should receive appropriate medical assessment. A mood score alone does not justify attributing pain to psychological factors.
The study does, however, highlight the value of considering mood alongside the physical assessment and listening carefully to how patients describe their pain.
Mood Scores Also Improved After Surgery
The researchers also compared depression and anxiety scores before and after surgery. In the lower preoperative depression score group, both scores decreased significantly at one year.
| HADS score (median) | Before surgery | One year after surgery |
|---|---|---|
| Depression | 2.5 | 0.5 |
| Anxiety | 3.5 | 0.5 |
* Values for the lower preoperative depression score group.
No significant changes were observed in the higher preoperative depression score group.
The authors suggested that relief from ankle pain and difficulty walking may have helped ease mild depressive and anxiety symptoms in some patients. This was their interpretation of the findings; the study did not investigate what caused the improvement in mood.
What Do These Findings Mean for Patients?
Low mood before surgery does not rule out improvements in function afterwards
Both groups in this study improved in ankle function and walking ability. Depression scores are one part of the preoperative assessment, and decisions about surgery require a broader clinical evaluation.
If pain persists after surgery, tell your doctor and describe it clearly
Explain where it hurts, when the pain occurs, how long it lasts, and how it affects walking and daily activities. These details help your doctor assess your recovery.
Mood deserves attention during the preoperative assessment
The authors noted the value of assessing depressive symptoms alongside the condition of the joint. However, the study did not test psychological or drug treatments, so it cannot tell us whether these would improve pain after ankle replacement.
What Are the Study’s Limitations?
The results describe what was observed in this particular group. They cannot predict how an individual patient will recover.
Frequently Asked Questions
About This Article
Written by
Ginza YR Clinic editorial team
Dr Junya Higuchi, director of Ginza YR Clinic, is the second author of the paper discussed in this article. At the time of the research, he worked in the Department of Orthopaedic Surgery at Teikyo University Mizonokuchi Hospital.
Medical information notice
This article draws on published research to provide general medical information. It does not guarantee any diagnosis, outcome or safety. The data were collected at other medical institutions and describe findings in a specific patient population. They cannot predict individual treatment outcomes.
Please discuss treatment options and symptoms after surgery with your treating doctor. This article is not intended to diagnose depression. If low mood or sleep problems persist, please consult an appropriate healthcare provider.
References
- Yasui T, Higuchi J, Kasai T, Yamada A, Kobata T, Hasebe K, Hara M. Association of Preoperative Depression Score With Outcomes of Transfibular Total Ankle Arthroplasty. The Journal of Foot & Ankle Surgery. 2023;62(5):807–811. https://doi.org/10.1053/j.jfas.2023.04.004
- Japanese Society for Surgery of the Foot. SAFE-Q (Self-Administered Foot Evaluation Questionnaire). https://www.jssf.jp/english/safeq.html
Last updated: 13 October 2026
